OSAGE COUNTY, OKLAHOMA – The Osage County Sheriff’s Office has made a second arrest in connection with the November 15, 2026, home invasion and robbery of a 70-year-old woman in the rural Webb City area near Shidler, Oklahoma.
The original incident occurred when a male suspect forced his way into the victim’s residence, assaulted her with a baseball bat, and bound her hands and feet before stealing approximately $10,000 in cash and other valuables.
On November 16, investigators identified Mark Allen Choney, 59, of Ponca City, as a suspect. Choney was subsequently located and detained by Ponca City Police and arrested and booked into the Osage County Jail.
As the investigation continued, investigators developed information connecting Christina Noel Sifferd, of Shidler, to the crime.
Investigators recovered a hand-drawn map of the victim’s residence during a search of Choney’s residence in Ponca City. The map detailed the interior layout of the victim’s home, including the location where the stolen money was believed to be kept.
Investigators also obtained surveillance footage showing Choney and Sifferd together at the Osage Casino in Ponca City on the morning of the robbery.
During a subsequent interview on November 17, Sifferd acknowledged assisting Choney in preparing the hand-drawn map of the victim’s residence and admitted knowing that Choney intended to go to the residence. Sifferd claimed she believed the victim would be away attending church when Choney entered the home.
Following the interview, Christina Noel Sifferd was arrested on complaints of Conspiracy to Commit a Felony and Obstruction and booked into the Osage County Jail.
This is an arrest not a conviction.
Sheriff Bart Perrier
Osage County Sheriff’s Office




















